What Makes You Break Up with a TV Show? | via givinguponperfect.com

The second season of The Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt was released on Netflix last week. Sadly for me, Mark got the stomach flu over the weekend and was here, hogging up my TV time, even more than usual. (Obviously, a stomach virus is sad for me because I love him and hate for him to be sick [and, don’t forget, I’m the Worst Nurse Ever]. I’m not a total monster. People.) But after rewatching the first season in just a few days, I was bummed to have to wait almost an entire week to start the new episodes.

So far, I’ve only watched the first two episodes of the second season, and they are just as outrageous and hilarious. The show is silly, sure, but it’s also smart and snarky with pointed asides and references. One of those jabs was having several characters rattle off detailed reports about the Kardashians and then mutter, “HOW DO I KNOW THAT?” The point, obviously, being that our news media covers ridiculous things, which results in a shared knowledge of ridiculous things that are not actually news. Or important.

Which brings me to today and my point (yes, I have one). I’ve read several Very Important news stories this past week, about serious things that are devastating, tragic, and often controversial. But what I want to talk to you about is not one of those things. I mean, it’s not the Kardashians, either. I have limits. But I do want to talk about Castle. And the fact that one of the lead actors in the show is leaving after this season.

Except, I don’t really want to talk about Castle. (Although, we could, as I have watched every single episode since the pilot.) What I want to talk about is the practice of quitting shows.

We’ve talked about what genres, tropes or themes make us shout, “Shut up and take my money!” And we’ve looked at the opposite situation, the things that make us shut a book, mark it DNF (did not finish), and walk away. Now I want to discuss the television version of this.

What Makes You Break Up with a TV Show? | via givinguponperfect.com

What makes you break up with a TV show? Are you a die-hard, in-it-till-the-end viewer? Or are you willing to pick up the remote and delete a show from your DVR at the slightest infraction? Like many of us said about the abundance of good books and our lack of free time, ain’t nobody got time for bad TV! (Unless it’s so-bad-it’s-good TV. That’s something completely different.)

Naturally, I’ve stopped watching shows when my schedule got too crowded or the show failed to keep my interest any longer. The Office was that kind of slow fade for me. I never decided that I was finished with Michael, Jim, Dwight and Pam. I just kind of fell out of love the with Dunder Mifflin crew and missed an episode here and there. Before I knew it, I had missed most of the last season. (Of course, my addiction to finales meant I tuned back in the last couple of months the show aired.)

The only shows I considered must-see favorites that I can recall full-stop QUITTING are Grey’s Anatomy, The Good Wife, Parenthood and Bones. Grey’s, Good Wife and Parenthood, in their own ways, got to be TOO MUCH for me. Too much drama, too much anxiety after watching it. So I cut them out of my viewing schedule.

But Bones? Well, I admit I stopped watching Bones because the show made me mad. Yep. I threw a TV tantrum and quit watching when the show made some changes I didn’t approve of. Because that’s what true fans do…right?

Well, yeah, based on the comment sections of articles about TV shows, that’s exactly what fans do! Two shows I’ve watched for years have major changes coming at the end of this season. Michael Weatherly (who plays Tony DiNozzo) is leaving NCIS, and — as it was just announced — Stana Katic (who plays Kate Beckett) is leaving Castle. Two major characters are leaving their shows, and fans are predictably in an uproar.

While I’m a bit weary of both shows and won’t complain if and when they’re finally cancelled, I won’t be breaking up with them over these cast changes. But the hubbub surrounding these decisions made me wonder: Would I quit other shows if certain characters left?

I don’t know. Maybe. Probably? I’m not sure, but I did think this would make a fun topic for a Friday chat. So let’s chat! Tell me: have you ever walked away from a formerly favorite show? what character is a deal breaker for you? what change would be too much or too far?

What makes you break up with a show?

What should you watch next?


Every month, we are bombarded with new TV series and movies—and it can be overwhelming to figure out what to watch! (I know, I know, what a problem to have!) I'm here to help. My monthly Watch Guides list out all the returning series, new series, and new movies, along with premiere dates and where to watch them. Plus, I tell you my personal picks for the month to help you narrow it all down.

Drop your name and email here, and I'll send you this month's Watch Guide right away!

(Signing up gives me permission to email you. But I will never, ever send you spam or junk. Who has time for that?!)

You have Successfully Subscribed!

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This